The loyalty tax: how set and forget loans quietly cost you thousands

If you have been with the same bank for years, there is a good chance you have asked yourself a simple question at some point. Am I still on a good deal?

Most borrowers assume loyalty is rewarded. You make repayments on time, you do the right thing, and you expect your lender to keep you competitive. The truth is a bit more uncomfortable.

Banks are businesses. They compete hardest for new customers, and they often reserve their sharpest pricing for people they are trying to win, not people who have already stayed.

That gap between what you could be paying and what you are paying is what we call the loyalty tax. It is not always obvious, and it does not usually show up as one dramatic change. It happens quietly, over time, when a loan is set up once and never reviewed again.

Why set and forget loans drift behind the market

Home loans do not stay equal across the board. Lenders change their pricing and policies constantly. Sometimes rates move with the market. Sometimes lenders reprice in ways that affect different loan types and customer groups differently.

If you are an existing customer and you do nothing, your loan often stays exactly as it is. You might not receive a notification that your rate is no longer competitive. You might not notice a small change in repayments. And if you have been paying the same way for years, it is easy to assume everything is fine.

But many borrowers are not overpaying because they made a bad decision. They are overpaying because they never checked again.

New customer pricing is real

One of the biggest reasons the loyalty tax exists is new customer pricing. Banks frequently market their most attractive offers to new borrowers. That is how they grow.

Existing customers, on the other hand, often sit on older pricing that is no longer aligned with the market. Even a small difference can add up over time. It may not feel dramatic in a weekly budget, but across a year, and then across multiple years, the gap can become significant.

This is why a home loan review matters even when your repayments are manageable. Comfort does not always mean value.

The retention team most people never trigger

Here is something most borrowers do not realise. Many lenders have retention teams. Their job is to keep customers from leaving.

But these teams are not usually proactive. They do not call existing customers and offer a better deal simply because they have been loyal. They respond when a customer starts comparing, reviewing, or preparing to move.

If you do not ask the question, you often do not get the best answer.

A proper loan review gives you a benchmark. It allows you to see what options exist, what your current lender is really offering, and whether staying put makes sense.

Sometimes the outcome is refinancing to a new lender. Sometimes the outcome is staying with your current lender, but on improved terms. Either way, you move from guessing to knowing.

Refinancing is not always the answer, but clarity is

The goal is not to refinance for the sake of refinancing. The goal is to make sure your loan still fits your life and still reflects the current market.

A review can uncover things like:

  • Your rate no longer being competitive
  • Your loan features not matching your goals
  • Your equity position improving, creating better options
  • Your fixed rate ending soon, which could cause repayment shock
  • A structure that could be optimised for flexibility or long term interest savings

Some people refinance to reduce repayments. Others refinance to shorten their loan term. Others refinance to set themselves up for upgrading, investing, or renovations. The right move depends on the goal.

How often should you review

A simple rule of thumb is to review your loan at least once a year, and any time your life changes. New job, pay rise, new baby, planning renovations, upgrading, or investing. These are all moments where your loan may need to evolve.

If it has been more than 12 months since your last review, it is worth checking where you stand. Not because something is wrong, but because being proactive can save you a lot of money and stress later.

Loyalty is a great trait, but it is not a home loan strategy. 

If your loan has been set and forgotten, there is a real chance you are paying a loyalty tax without realising it.

The fix is simple. Review your loan, understand your options, and make a decision based on facts.

Book your free discovery call today
🌐 www.financelane.com.au

refinancing

Latest Articles

Let’s Find a New Direction. Together.

Buying, building, or refinancing? We’ll tailor a solution that’s as strategic as it is stress-free. Book your free consult now and take the next step with confidence.

Got Questions? We’ve Got You.

Finance can feel like a maze - we’re here to make it make sense. Whether you’re buying your first home or scaling your business, these answers will help clear the fog. Still unsure? Let’s chat it through.
Do I need to have a 20% deposit to get a home loan?
Not necessarily. While a 20% deposit avoids Lender’s Mortgage Insurance (LMI), there are options with as little as 5% down. We’ll help you navigate what’s best based on your situation.
LMI is a fee charged when your deposit is under 20%. It protects the lender, not you, but we can often help you avoid it or reduce the impact through specific loan structures or profession-based waivers.
It depends on your income, expenses, credit history, and current financial commitments. We use detailed tools and lender calculators to give you a realistic, tailored figure.
If your documentation is ready, pre-approval can happen within 1–3 business days. Full approval after a purchase usually takes 5–7 business days, depending on the lender.